CASE SUMMARY
On January 31, 2024, twelve plaintiffs filed a civil action in the Western District of Louisiana alleging Louisiana's newly enacted congressional map violates the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments of the United States Constitution.
A consolidated preliminary injunction hearing and trial was held April 8-10, 2024.
On April 30, 2024, the court ruled 2-1 that SB8 violated the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment and enjoined its use for future elections. The court held a status conference on May 6, 2024, to determine next steps in the remedial proceedings. The next day the court issued a scheduling order allowing the state until June 3 to enact a new plan. If the state does not do so the court will impose a map on June 4, 2024.
After the Western District issued its scheduling order the state and defendant-intervenors filed applications for emergency stays pending appeal with the Supreme Court of the United States. The Supreme Court granted the emergency applications for a stay on May 15, 2024, citing Purcell v. Gonzalez.
The state of Louisiana, the Robinson-intervenors, and the Galmon proposed intervenors filed their jurisdictional statements on July 30, 2024, and the Callais Plaintiffs filed their motions to Dismiss or Affirm on September 3, 2024.
The Supreme Court listed the appeals for consideration at its October 11, 2024, conference. The Court dismissed the Galmon's appeal for lack of jurisdiction on October 15th and then relisted the state and Robinson appeals for the October 18, 2024, conference and again for the November 1, 2024, conference. The Court subsequently noted probable jurisdiction in both Louisiana v. Callais and Robinson v. Callais, consolidated the cases, and allotted one hour for oral argument.
CASE LIBRARY
U.S. District Court for the Western District of Louisiana - No. 3:24-cv-122
- Complaint - 1/31/24
- Summons in a Civil Action - 1/31/24
- Order Constituting a Three-Judge Court - 2/2/24
- Motion to Intervene - 2/6/24
- Plaintiffs' Request to Exceed Brief Page Length - 2/6/24
- Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction, Exhibits B-Z, Exhibits AA-RR - 2/7/24
- Motion to Intervene as Defendants and Transfer - 2/7/24
- Order - 2/8/24
- Amended Certificate of Service - 2/8/24
- Summons Returned Executed - 2/9/24
- Notice Regarding Service - 2/9/24
- Plaintiffs' Response to Motions to Intervene and Motion to Transfer - 2/14/24
- Unopposed Motion for Case Management Conference and Expedited Schedule - 2/19/24
- Memorandum in Support of Unopposed Motion for Case Management Conference and Expedited Schedule - 2/19/24
- [Proposed] Order - 2/19/24
- The State of Louisiana's Motion to Intervene - 2/20/24
- Notice of Intervenors' Position and Request for Leave to Participate in the Case Management Conference - 2/21/24
- Scheduling Order - 2/21/24
- Answer to Complaint - 2/22/24
- Galmon Proposed Intervenors' Reply in Support of Motion to Intervene - 2/23/24
- Robinson Movants' Reply in Support of Motion to Intervene - 2/23/24
- Order - 2/26/24
- Intervenor-Defendant the State of Louisiana's Answer and Affirmative Defenses - 2/26/24
- [Proposed] Answer of Intervenor-Defendants to Plaintiffs' Complaint - 2/26/24
- Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction by Defendant Secretary of State - 2/27/24
- Unopposed Motion and Memorandum [...] of Galmon Amici in Opposition to Motion for Preliminary Injunction - 2/27/24
- Intervenor-Defendant's Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction - 2/27/24
- Robinson Plaintiffs' Request for Leave to File Amicus Brief in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction - 2/27/24
- Order - 2/29/24
- Order - 2/29/24
- Plaintiffs' Unopposed Motion to Exceed Brief Page Length - 3/1/24
- Galmon Movants' Motion to Reconsider Order Denying Intervention - 3/1/24
- Galmon Movants' Memorandum in Support of Their Motion to Reconsider Order Denying Intervention - 3/1/24
- Galmon Movants' Motion to Expedite Briefing on Their Motion to Reconsider Order Denying Intervention - 3/7/24
- Plaintiffs' Reply in Support of Motion for Preliminary Injunction - 3/8/24
- Robinson Movants' Motion to Reconsider Intervention Order and to Expedite Briefing on the Motion - 3/9/24
- The State of Louisiana's Response to Galmon Movants' Motion to Reconsider Order Denying Intervention - 3/11/24
- Plaintiffs' Motion for Leave to File a Response in Opposition to Motion for Reconsideration - 3/11/24
- The State of Louisiana's Response to Robinson Movants' Motion to Reconsider Order Denying Intervention - 3/12/24
- Galmon Movants' Motion for Leave to File a Reply in Support of Their Motion to Reconsider Order Denying Intervention - 3/12/24
- Plaintiffs' Motion for Leave to File a Response in Opposition to Robinson Motion for Reconsideration - 3/13/24
- Robinson Movants' Motion for Leave to File a Reply in Support of Their Motion to Reconsider Order Denying Intervention - 3/13/24
- Order - 3/15/24
- Plaintiffs' Objection to Galmon Movants' Motion to Reconsider Order Denying Intervention - 3/15/24
- Galmon Movants' Reply in Support of Their Motion to Reconsider Order Denying Intervention - 3/15/24
- Plaintiffs' Opposition to Robinson Movants' Motion to Reconsider Order Denying Intervention - 3/15/24
- Robinson Movants' Reply in Support of Their Motion to Reconsider Intervention Order - 3/15/24
- Galmon Movants' Notice of Appeal Regarding Denial of Intervention - 3/20/24
- Minutes of Court - 3/22/24
- Galmon Movants' Transcript Request - 3/25/24
- Order - 3/26/24
- Defendant's Exhibit List - 4/1/24
- Intervenor Defendant The State of Louisiana's Corrected Witness and Exhibit List - 4/1/24
- Plaintiffs' Exhibit and Witness Lists - 4/1/24
- Robinson Intervenors' List of Exhibits and Witnesses for The Consolidated Hearing - 4/1/24
- Robinson Intervenors' Motion for Leave to Allow Anthony Fairfax and Royce Duplessis to Testify at Trial Remotely Via Videoconferencing - 4/2/24
- Robinson Intervenors' Motion in Limine - 4/2/24
- Robinson Intervenors' Motion to Strike Improper Rebuttal Testimony [...] or Present Responsive Expert Testimony - 4/3/24
- Plaintiffs' Response to Intervenors' Omnibus Motion in Limine - 4/3/24
- Minutes of Court - 4/4/24
- Plaintiffs' Response to Intervenors' Motion to Strike - 4/5/24
- Robinson Intervenors' Motion to Reconsider Denial of Leave to Present Responsive Expert Testimony - 4/5/24
- Joint Stipulations for April 8, 2024 Bench Trial - 4/5/24
- Intervenor Defendant the State of Louisiana's Second Corrected Witness and Exhibit List - 4/6/24
- Plaintiffs' Response to Intervenors' Motion to Reconsider Exclusion of Sur-Rebuttal Expert Lisa Handley and Exhibit - 4/6/24
- Robinson Intervenors' Motion for Continuance or, in the Alternative, to Deconsolidate Preliminary Hearing from the Merits Trial - 4/6/24
- Plaintiffs' Response in Opposition to Motion to Continue - 4/7/24
- The Parties' Designations of the 2024 First Legislative Session - 4/7/24
- The Robinson Intervenors' Designations of the 2024 First Legislative Session - 4/9/24
- Minutes of Court (Bench Trial Day 1) - 4/8/24
- Joint Exhibit List - 4/9/24
- Minutes of Court (Bench Trial Day 2) - 4/9/24
- Intervenor Defendant the State of Louisiana's third Amended Witness and Exhibit List - 4/10/24
- Robinson Intervenors' Third Amended List of Exhibits and Witnesses for the Consolidated Hearing - 4/10/24
- Minutes of Court (Bench Trial Day 3) - 4/10/24
- Joint Exhibit List - 4/10/24
- Motion and Memorandum Requesting Leave to File Post-Trial Amicus Curiae Brief of Galmon Amici - 4/17/24
- Robinson Intervenors' Post-Trial Memorandum, Proposed Findings of Fact, and [Proposed] Order [...] - 4/17/24
- Plaintiffs' Post-Trial Brief - 4/17/24
- Plaintiffs' Proposed Findings of Fact - 4/17/24
- State of Louisiana's Post-Trial Brief - 4/17/24
- Defendant's Post-Trial Brief - 4/17/24
- Intervenor-Defendant the State of Louisiana's Proposed Findings of Fact - 4/17/24
- Galmon Amici's Post-Trial Amicus Brief - 4/19/24
- Injunction and Reasons for Judgment - 4/30/24
- Robinson Intervenor-Defendants' Notice of Appeal - 5/1/24
- Robinson Intervenors' Motion for Stay Pending Appeal - 5/1/24
- Robinson Intervenors' [Proposed] Order - 5/1/24
- Plaintiffs' Response in Opposition to Robinson Intervenors' Motion to Stay Pending Appeal - 5/2/24
- Order Denying Motion to Stay Pending Appeal - 5/3/24
- Order - 5/3/24
- Motion for Leave to File Brief Amicus Curiae in Support of Neither Party and to Exceed the Page Limit - 5/3/24
- Motion for Leave to Attend May 6 Status Conference - 5/3/24
- Brief Amici Curiae in Support of Neither Party - 5/6/24
- Minutes of Court: Status Conference - 5/6/24
- Defendant's Brief Regarding Election Deadlines - 5/6/24
- The State of Louisiana's Scheduling Brief - 5/6/24
- Scheduling Order - 5/7/24
- The State of Louisiana's Notice of Appeal - 5/7/24
- The State of Louisiana's and Secretary of State's Amended Notice of Appeal - 5/7/24
- The State of Louisiana's and the Secretary of State's Joint Motion for A Stay Pending Appeal - 5/8/24
- Order - 5/9/24
- Robinson and Galmon Intervenors' Motion for Clarification and Reconsideration - 5/9/24
- Plaintiffs' Opposition to Robinson and Galmon Intervenors' Motion [...] and Cross-Motion [...] - 5/10/24
- Robinson and Galmon Intervenors' Reply in Support of Their Motion for Clarification and Reconsideration [...] - 5/14/24
- Motion for Leave to File Brief for the Project on Fair Representation as Amici Curiae Regarding Remedies - 5/15/24
- Brief for the Project on Fair Representation as Amicus Curiae Regarding Remedies - 5/16/24
- Notice of Order Granting Motion to Supplement the Record - 5/21/24
- Galmon Movants' Notice of Appeal - 5/30/24
- Letter from the Clerk of the Supreme Court of the United States - 11/12/24
- Letter from the Clerk of the Supreme Court of the United States - 11/12/24
United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit - No. 24-30177
- Notice of Appeal - 3/20/24
- Letter from the Deputy Clerk of the Fifth Circuit - 3/22/24
- Docketing Notice - 3/25/24
- Galmon Movants-Appellants' Motion to Expedite Appeal - 3/25/24
- Order Denying Motion to Expedite Appeal - 03/26/24
- Letter to the Clerk of the Fifth Circuit Regarding the Passing of Thomas A. Farr - 4/8/24
- Docketing and Scheduling Notice - 4/16/24
- Galmon Movants-Appellants' Motion to Correct Caption - 4/23/24
- Galmon Movants-Appellants' Opening Brief - 4/26/24
- Galmon Movants-Appellants' Record Excerpts - 4/26/24
- Motion to Supplement the Record & Order - 5/21/24
- Notice of Resumption of Briefing Schedule - 6/13/24
- Brief of Plaintiffs-Appellees - 6/17/24
- Joint Notice Regarding Appellee Brief - 7/2/24
- Galmon Movants-Appellants' Reply Brief - 7/8/24
- Notice from the Clerk of the Fifth Circuit - 7/26/24
- Galmon Movants-Appellants' Reply Brief - 9/6/24
- Galmon Movants-Appellants' Opposed Motion to Stay Proceedings Pending Clarification by Supreme Court - 9/11/24
- Order - 9/17/24
- Letter from Appellees notifying the Clerk of the Court of U.S. Supreme Court's Dismissal of Galmon v. Callais for Lack of Jurisdiction - 10/15/24
Supreme Court of the United States - No. 23A1002 (Landry v. Callais)
- Emergency Application for Stay Pending Appeal - 5/10/24
- Addendum - 5/10/24
- Declaration of Sherri Wharton Hadskey - 5/10/24
- Brief for Edward Galmon [...] as Amici Curiae in Support of Applicants - 5/10/24
- Response to Emergency Applications for Stay Pending Appeal and for Stay of Injunction - 5/13/24
- Reply in Support of Emergency Application for Stay Pending Appeal - 5/14/24
- Motion for Leave to File Sur-Reply - 5/14/24
- Order - 5/15/24
Supreme Court of the United States - 24-109 (formerly No. 23A1142) (Louisiana v. Callais)
- Joint Application to Extend Time to File Jurisdictional Statements and Exhibits - 6/18/24
- Response to Joint Application to Extend Time to File Jurisdictional Statements - 6/18/24
- Notice of Order Extending Time to File Jurisdictional Statements - 6/27/24
- Jurisdictional Statement - 7/30/24
- Letter Rule 18.2 of Nancy Landry, the Secretary of State of Louisiana - 8/1/24
- Motion to Dismiss or Affirm - 9/3/24
- Brief for [Galmon Amici] as Amici Curiae in Support of Neither Party - 9/3/24
- Brief of Alabama and 12 Other States as Amici Curiae in Support of No Party - 9/3/24
- Brief Opposing Motion to Dismiss or Affirm - 9/17/24
- Order Noting Jurisdiction - 11/4/24
- Questions Presented - 11/4/24
- Motion of Galmon Movants to Intervene - 11/20/24
- Appellant's Opposition to Motion of Galmon Movants to Intervene - 12/2/24
- Response to Motion for Leave to Intervene - 12/2/24
- Galmon Movants' Reply in Support of Motion to Intervene - 12/5/24
- Order Denying Motion of Galmon Movants (p.2) - 12/9/24
Supreme Court of the United States - 24-110 (formerly No. 23A994) (Robinson v. Callais)
- Emergency Application for Stay of Injunction - 5/8/24
- Lower Court Orders/Opinions - 5/8/24
- Brief for Edward Galmon [...] as Amici Curiae in Support of Applicants - 5/10/24
- Response to Emergency Applications for Stay Pending Appeal and for Stay of Injunction - 5/13/24
- Reply in Support of Application for Stay - 5/14/24
- Order - 5/15/24
- Jurisdictional Statement & Appendix Part I and Part II - 7/30/24
- Motion to Dismiss or Affirm - 9/3/24
- Brief of Alabama and 12 Other States as Amici Curiae in Support of No Party - 9/3/24
- Brief Opposing Motion to Dismiss or Affirm - 9/16/24
- Order Noting Jurisdiction - 11/4/24
- Questions Presented - 11/4/24
Supreme Court of the United States - 24-111 (Galmon v. Callais)
- Jurisdictional Statement & Appendix - 7/30/24
- Motion to Dismiss or Affirm - 9/3/24
- Opposition to Motion to Dismiss or Affirm - 9/17/24
- Order Dismissing the Appeal for Lack of Jurisdiction - 10/15/24